Government lawyer concedes UMFA’s constitutional rights violated during 2016 bargaining, argues $28 million in damages would be unfair to taxpayers
Lawyers for the Manitoba government acknowledged in the Court of Queen’s Bench on Tuesday it was unconstitutional for the provincial government in 2016 to impose a secret bargaining mandate when the University of Manitoba and the University of Manitoba Faculty Association (UMFA) were in the middle of contract talks.
“It was wrong and it was unconstitutional and it’s deserving of a remedy,” Heather Leonoff, a lawyer for the Manitoba government told Justice Joan McKelvey. “It caused a problem to keep this secret for a period of three weeks…to keep the union in the dark.”
“No effective bargaining could take place during those three weeks because one side knew something the other didn’t know.”
UMFA is seeking more than $28 million in damages. Lawyers for the union argued Monday the university withdrew an offer for a total wage increase of 17.5 per cent over four years when the government interfered in negotiations, pursuant to a political directive, and asked the university to keep it secret.
UMFA lawyer Garth Smorang argued UMFA members would have received the increase and a 21-day strike would have been averted had the government not interfered.
Leonoff disagreed.
“We cannot say for sure what the terms of it would have been,” Leonoff told the court. “Pure speculation exactly what the 2016 contract would’ve looked like.”
While the government’s lawyers conceded there was a violation, they argued UMFA ultimately agreed in 2016 to a one-year contract with a zero per cent wage increase after learning about the mandate.
Leonoff argued mandates and wage restraint legislation aren’t unlawful and that the court should only award damages for the three-week period during which UMFA did not know about the mandate.
“Now they come to court and say we want damages for the deal we accepted,” she told the court.
Leonoff argued that the UMFA’s proposed remedy of more than $28 million would be unfair to taxpayers, telling the court if the union didn’t like the one-year deal, they could’ve chosen not to accept.
“It’s not an appropriate and just remedy,” Leonoff argued. “It’s seeking compensation for four years of its decisions it doesn’t want to live with.”
“How is this fair to the taxpayer? These are all decisions the union made.”
Smorang told the court UMFA takes issue with that argument.
“Everything that was done, not only by the union, but by the university itself after Oct. 27 (2016), was done as a reaction to and as a result of government unconstitutional actions,” Smorang argued.
Leonoff suggested in court a range of $500 to $1,000 per UMFA member would be a more appropriate remedy.
UMFA’s proposal would see the average member receive $13,500 each.
Justice McKelvey has reserved her decision.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
MPP Sarah Jama asked to leave Ontario legislature for wearing keffiyeh
MPP Sarah Jama was asked to leave the Legislative Assembly of Ontario by House Speaker Ted Arnott on Thursday for wearing a keffiyeh, a garment which has been banned at Queen’s Park.
Mountain guide dies after falling into a crevasse in Banff National Park
A man who fell into a crevasse while leading a backcountry ski group deep in the Canadian Rockies has died.
B.C. tenants evicted for landlord's use after refusing large rent increase to take over neighbouring suite
Ashley Dickey and her mother rented part of the same Coquitlam duplex in three different decades under three different landlords.
Expert warns of food consumption habits amid rising prices
A new survey by Dalhousie University's Agri-Food Analytics Lab asked Canadians about their food consumption habits amid rising prices.
Saskatchewan isn't remitting the carbon tax on home heating. Why isn't my province following suit?
After Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said the federal government would still send Canada Carbon Rebate cheques to Saskatchewan residents, despite Saskatchewan Premier Scott Moe's decision to stop collecting the carbon tax on natural gas or home heating, questions were raised about whether other provinces would follow suit. CTV News reached out across the country and here's what we found out.
Montreal actress calls Weinstein ruling 'discouraging' but not surprising
A Montreal actress, who has previously detailed incidents she had with disgraced Hollywood producer Harvey Weinstein, says a New York Court of Appeals decision overturning his 2020 rape conviction is 'discouraging' but not surprising.
RCMP officers had no legal authority to enter man's home, make arrest: B.C. court
A B.C. man has been found not guilty of assaulting two RCMP officers – with the court finding he was resisting an "unlawful entry and arrest" in his home before he was tasered, taken down and hauled away in handcuffs.
Body of Quebec man who died in Cuba found in Russia, family confirms
A Montreal-area family confirmed to CTV News that the body of their loved one who died while on vacation in Cuba is being repatriated to Canada after it was mistakenly sent to Russia.
'Deep ignorance': Calls for Manitoba trustee to resign sparked after comments about Indigenous people and reconciliation
A rural Manitoba school trustee is facing calls to resign over comments he made about Indigenous people and residential schools earlier this week.