Legal battle dismissed between firefighter, paramedic suing each other
(File image)
A legal battle has been dismissed between a city firefighter and paramedic who sued each other over allegations of racism and defamation.
On Nov. 30, in Manitoba's Court of King's Bench, Justice Herbert Rempel dismissed the legal actions between firefighter Kelcey French and paramedic Nishanth Jayaranjan.
Both French and Jayaranjan will be paying their own costs, according to a written judgment.
It brings to a close a legal battle between the two men that started more than two years ago.
French first filed a statement of claim against Jayaranjan, alleging he was the target of a 'defamatory campaign' stemming from an Oct. 7, 2020, emergency call.
READ MORE: Winnipeg firefighter sues paramedic for $600K alleging defamation in accusations of racism
According to the claim, French attended to an Indigenous woman who was suffering from a self-inflicted stab wound to the neck.
The claim says when French got in the ambulance Jayaranjan was "hostile and aggressive," insulting him with "profanity and slurs." It goes on to allege Jayaranjan, "deliberately falsified a patient care report" to make it look like he did not care for the victim promptly, and sent an email to the fire chief and 10 others saying French refused to help Jayaranjan during the emergency call, alleging this was "racially motivated."
The events prompted a third-party review of the incident.
The claim goes on to allege Jayaranjan sent the email to a Winnipeg reporter leading to an article about the incident, and used an anonymous Reddit account to post, "further defamatory comments."
Jayaranjan then filed a statement of defence and counterclaim against French, denying the allegations in his claim.
READ MORE: Winnipeg paramedic files counterclaim in defamation suit filed by firefighter
Jayaranjan's defence and counterclaim alleged French had been the one who was hostile and aggressive, and did not assess the patient. The counterclaim said Jayaranjan believed French's refusal to provide service and his hostile behaviour was motivated by complaints he previously brought forward relating to “racism within the WFPS.”
The written judgment does not disclose the reasons why the matter is being dismissed.
None of the allegations in the claim and counterclaim were tested in court.
Derek Olson, the lawyer representing Jayaranjan, told CTV News the matter had been resolved but was not able to provide any further details.
CTV News has reached out French's lawyer for comment.
Shopping Trends
The Shopping Trends team is independent of the journalists at CTV News. We may earn a commission when you use our links to shop. Read about us.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Calgary woman stranded in Mexico after husband's death during diving trip
A Calgary woman is struggling to return home after her husband died while diving in Mexico, leaving her stranded and facing financial hardship.
Special national Liberal caucus meeting called for next week after regional chairs meet: sources
A special meeting of Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's national Liberal caucus has been called for next Wednesday, sources say.
'Inadmissible' foreign nationals to pay more upon return to Canada: CBSA
Foreign nationals who refuse or are unable to pay their own way home after being denied stay in Canada will soon face steeper financial penalties should they ever attempt to return.
N.S. community shocked by deaths of father, daughter; suspect was wanted in Toronto shooting
A Nova Scotia community is mourning the loss of two of its members after they were shot and killed in Halifax on New Year's Eve.
Sea and Himalayan salts recalled in Canada: 'Do not use, serve or distribute'
Two brands of sea and Himalayan salt are being recalled in Canada due to pieces of plastic found in the products.
Soldier who blew up Tesla at Trump hotel left note saying blast was to be a 'wakeup call' for the U.S.
A highly decorated Army soldier who fatally shot himself in a Tesla Cybertruck just before it blew up outside the Trump hotel in Las Vegas left notes saying the New Year's Day explosion was a stunt to serve as a “wakeup call” for the country’s ills, investigators said Friday.
'It's about time': Experts in Canada support call for warnings about cancer risk from alcohol
While Canada hasn't mandated cancer warnings for alcoholic beverages, a few experts are supporting a new push in the U.S. to have the labels on the products.
'Mystery volcano' that erupted and cooled Earth in 1831 has finally been identified
An unknown volcano erupted so explosively in 1831 that it cooled Earth's climate. Now, nearly 200 years later, scientists have identified the 'mystery volcano.'
Judge sets Trump's sentencing in hush money case for Jan. 10, but signals no jail time
In an extraordinary turn, a judge Friday set U.S. president-elect Donald Trump's sentencing in his hush money case for Jan. 10, but indicated he wouldn't be jailed.
Regina
-
Sask. RCMP investigating woman's death on Piapot First Nation
Saskatchewan RCMP says it is investigating the death of a 30-year-old woman on Piapot First Nation as suspicious in nature.
-
SaskAbilites Yorkton enhances relaxation room
SaskAbilities Yorkton has enhanced their relaxation room to help people with disabilities experience a more comfortable and calming environment.
-
CTV Regina's top trending stories of 2024
Whether it was hard news or light-hearted features, the year of 2024 hosted some very compelling stories – with several being widely shared online and reaching new audiences.
Saskatoon
-
$20k of equipment stolen from rural Sask. Fire hall. And it's not the only one
Rural firehalls surrounding Saskatoon are having to deal with escalating thefts that could put rescue efforts in jeopardy.
-
Two people charged with murder after suspicious death on Sask. First Nation
A man and a woman have been charged with first degree murder after a 24-year-old man died of injuries on Saulteaux First Nation.
-
Inmate who escaped federal prison in Saskatchewan arrested
After about five months of searching, police have arrested Jareth Gardipy-Taypotat, who escaped from the Willow Cree Healing Lodge, a minimum-security federal institution north of Saskatoon.
Edmonton
-
Homicide investigation underway after woman found dead on Edmonton riverbank
Police have identified a woman who was recently found dead on the shore of the North Saskatchewan River in Edmonton.
-
'Flames were shooting higher than the garage': Block heater cords cause 2 fires in 2 days in Edmonton
Peter Claffey was shocked Thursday morning to find his truck in flames outside his southwest Edmonton home.
-
Gas leak slows traffic on 111 Avenue Friday night
Drivers were asked to avoid 111 Avenue near 11 Street due to a gas leak on Friday night.
Calgary
-
Calgary woman stranded in Mexico after husband's death during diving trip
A Calgary woman is struggling to return home after her husband died while diving in Mexico, leaving her stranded and facing financial hardship.
-
Calgary police seek driver of 'red vehicle' wanted in serious hit-and-run on Memorial Drive
Calgary police are hoping to gain more information from the public on a hit-and-run in November that badly injured one person.
-
Third person charged with first-degree murder in Lethbridge motel death
A third person has been charged with first-degree murder after a woman was found dead in a Lethbridge motel room over the weekend.
Toronto
-
2 Royal Military College students jumped into action to save a man from a burning car in North York
A black Ford Mustang had lost control while traveling north along Bayview, crashing into cement pillars near the stores loading dock.
-
Union representing Ontario college faculty issues five-day strike notice
Ontario college students could soon see their winter semester cut short as the union representing faculty at the province’s 24 public colleges could walk off the job as early as Thursday next week.
-
2024 was record-setting year for precipitation at Toronto airport: Environment Canada
Environment Canada says two massive summer storms helped catapult Toronto’s Pearson International Airport to its wettest year on record.
Ottawa
-
Highrise fire on Ramsey Crescent displaces 39 residents, injures 16
The Ottawa Paramedic Service says four adult women were taken to hospital following a fire that happened in a highrise on Ramsey Crescent, in the west end of Ottawa, in the early hours of Friday morning.
-
Man, woman seriously injured following multi-vehicle collision on Bank Street
A man and a woman were seriously injured following a multi-vehicle collision on Bank Street at Lester Road Friday afternoon, according to the Ottawa Paramedic Service.
-
OTTAWA'S LRT
OTTAWA'S LRT All aboard Ottawa's new LRT line: What you need to know about the new north-south Line 2 and Line 4
Ottawa’s new north-south rail line will open to the public on Monday, Jan. 6, connecting downtown Ottawa and Riverside South with a spur to the Ottawa International Airport.
Montreal
-
Lachine tenants have been out of heat and hot water for 2 months
A 47-unit building hasn't had hot water for nearly two months, and the heat is out too, forcing the city to intervene.
-
More homeless people hiding from the cold in Montreal's crowded ERs
When warming centres are full, homeless people with nowhere to go are turning to emergency rooms.
-
Montreal police make 2 more arrests in killing of Claudia Iacono
Montreal police have arrested two more suspects in the slaying of Claudia Iacono.
Atlantic
-
N.S. community shocked by deaths of father, daughter; suspect was wanted in Toronto shooting
A Nova Scotia community is mourning the loss of two of its members after they were shot and killed in Halifax on New Year's Eve.
-
Saint John man charged with second-degree murder in wife’s Christmas Eve death
A man accused of murdering his wife on Christmas Eve made his first court appearance in Saint John, N.B., Friday morning.
-
Winter storm watch issued in Cape Breton; Weather statements expanded in N.S. and P.E.I.
A major winter storm is expected to hit eastern parts of the Maritimes Sunday into Monday.
Vancouver
-
Fugitive U.S. rioter seeks asylum in Whistler amid warnings of more to come
An American citizen convicted of participating in the Jan. 6, 2021, riot on Capitol Hill and dodging jail time in Whistler may just be the start of an asylum-seeking rush, according to a prominent legal expert.
-
Former Four Seasons Hotel in downtown Vancouver to be demolished
A former luxury hotel tower in downtown Vancouver is slated to be demolished.
-
Accused in armed robbery at Vancouver Holt Renfrew has prior convictions
The 66-year-old man accused of holding up a Holt Renfrew in downtown Vancouver this week has prior convictions, including for two other robberies that involved fake guns.
Vancouver Island
-
B.C. driver who tried to apprehend suspected impaired driver was impaired: RCMP
Mounties on Vancouver Island say a 50-year-old motorist who tried to apprehend a suspected impaired driver on New Year's Eve, was, in fact, impaired and was issued a 90-day driving prohibition by police.
-
Attending hundreds of serious crash scenes each year takes its toll, B.C. first responders say
Just days into the new year, officials are already pleading with British Columbians to follow the rules of the road.
-
Woman, 63, dead after collision on Vancouver Island
A 63-year-old woman is dead after the car she was driving collided with a truck on southern Vancouver Island.
Kelowna
-
Charges laid after child porn investigation that 'spanned several different countries,' Kelowna RCMP say
Police in Kelowna say an international investigation has led to child pornography charges against a 46-year-old man.
-
Mounties investigate discovery of 'very small pipe bomb' in Kamloops, B.C.
Mounties are investigating and appealing for witnesses after an explosive device was discovered Wednesday on a beach in Kamloops, B.C.
-
Kamloops couple delivers B.C.'s first baby of 2025
B.C.'s first baby of 2025 was born just after midnight at Royal Inland Hospital in Kamloops.
N.L.
-
Labradorians pay thousands to fly to Newfoundland. Could a Quebec energy deal help?
An airport executive in Labrador hopes a new energy deal with Quebec could help attract a competing airline company to the northern region, where flights costs have climbed at more than three times the national rate.
-
Icebreaker on hand in Labrador to guide season's last freight arrivals by ferry
A Canadian Coast Guard icebreaker is in central Labrador until Saturday to guide the Kamutik W ferry on its last freight deliveries of the season.
-
Whooping cough in Canada: Outbreaks or case increases reported in these provinces
Canadian health officials say they're seeing spikes in whooping cough cases in parts of the country as the U.S. deals with case numbers not seen in more than a decade.
Northern Ontario
-
Suspect charged in northern Ont. road rage incident that went viral
A 37-year-old suspect has been charged in connection with a road rage incident last week in Temiskaming Shores.
-
Northern staff react to Ontario college faculties issuing five-day notice of labour action
College faculty in Ontario gave its five-day notice of starting labour action on Friday, which could include a strike or some other work stoppage at the 24 schools within the province.
-
Sault, Ont., man claims Indigenous moose hunting rights without proof, fined $5,500
A hunter from Sault Ste. Marie, Ont., has been fined for moose hunting without a licence or proper documentation. He claimed Indigenous hunting rights but failed to provide any proof.
Barrie
-
Persistent snow squalls bring heavy accumulations to Barrie area
Environment Canada is maintaining its snow squall warning for most of central Ontario on Friday.
-
Warrant issued for allegedly armed and dangerous man wanted for attempted murder
Police in York Region have issued an arrest warrant for one man following a reported shooting at a motel in Queensville.
-
Fail-to-remain driver busted hours after collision
A Cambridge man was busted in Caledon for a Brampton collision.
Kitchener
-
Snow squall warnings for southwestern Ontario
Environment Canada says southwestern Ontario could get between 15 and 60 centimetres of snow by Saturday.
-
Union representing Ontario college faculty issues five-day strike notice
Ontario college students could soon see their winter semester cut short as the union representing faculty at the province’s 24 public colleges could walk off the job as early as Thursday next week.
-
Renewed drinking and driving concerns amid results of Festive R.I.D.E. campaigns
New numbers from recent Festive R.I.D.E. check events show drinking and driving is still a big problem.
London
-
'Justice has been done': Man who fatally shot teen at bush party guilty of second degree murder
Carlos Guerra Guerra has been found guilty of second-degree murder in the 2021 bush party murder trial.
-
Road conditions deteriorate in areas north of London
Several areas in midwestern Ontario have had a snow squall watch upgraded to a snow squall warning.
-
College faculty could walk off the job as of January 9
Following months of anticipation, discussion, and bargaining, the Ontario Public Service Employees Union (OPSEU) is one step closer to walking off the job.
