Federal Court rejects Manitoba's argument against carbon price backstop
The Manitoba government has lost a two-year-long court battle against the federal government's carbon pricing plan.
A Federal Court judge has rejected Manitoba's argument that Ottawa should not have imposed an escalating minimum price on carbon, because the province was planning its own emissions plan that could have been just as effective.
"The (Ottawa) decisions were consistent with the statutory purpose of reducing (greenhouse gas) emissions by putting a price on them," Justice Richard Mosely wrote in a judgment released Tuesday.
"The inclusion of Manitoba on the list (of provinces subject to federally imposed pricing) was consistent with the statutory purpose and the guideline of ensuring that emissions pricing is applied broadly in Canada."
Former Manitoba premier Brian Pallister planned to have a flat $25 per tonne price on carbon. That was lower than the federal figure, but Pallister said Manitoba deserved credit for billions of dollars spent on clean hydroelectric projects, which utility customers continue to pay for.
Ottawa brought in a "backstop" carbon price on provinces that did not develop a carbon-pricing or cap-and-trade plan that met or exceeded the federal one. Saskatchewan, Alberta and Ontario argued the federal government was interfering in provincial jurisdiction. The Supreme Court of Canada ruled last March that Ottawa was within its constitutional authority.
The Manitoba government continued with its more limited court argument that the federal government has no right to impose a carbon pricing plan in a province where one already exists to reduce emissions equally.
Pallister said Manitoba's emissions plan, which included wetlands improvements and subsidies for fuel efficiency in the trucking industry, could meet or exceed federal targets without imposing a high carbon tax.
The judge said not only was Manitoba's plan not enacted at the time of the court challenge, the province's math was wrong.
"Manitoba relies on a misreading of its own evidence," Mosley wrote.
"According to Manitoba's own evidence, Manitoba's plan is 76,000 tonnes of CO2 (equivalent) lesseffective in 2022 than a price in accordance with the (federal criteria)."
Pallister stepped down as premier last month. There was no immediate comment from the Progressive Conservative government.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Oct. 26, 2021.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
BREAKING Some BMO clients face outages in Canada, U.S.
Bank of Montreal clients on both sides of the border Thursday morning have reported outages for banking services.
NEW How car thefts are impacting your insurance, even if your car isn't stolen
As the number of auto theft incidents rises in Canada, so have insurance premiums for drivers, even the ones whose vehicles aren't stolen.
B.C. mortgage broker ran $270-million Ponzi scheme, then fled Canada, bankruptcy trustee says
The trustee appointed to manage the bankruptcies of a Victoria mortgage company and its owner has concluded that they committed "numerous offences" and operated as a "massive Ponzi scheme."
'I'm not wealthy': Ontario senior shocked she owes $40,000 in capital gains after gifting land
An Ontario senior who wanted to help her daughter and grandson eventually own homes one day decided to give them two lots on her property as a gift—but she didn’t know it would eventually cost her tens of thousands of dollars.
opinion Trump's Republicans falling far behind in fundraising, infrastructure
In his latest column for CTVNews.ca, Washington political analyst Eric Ham explains how and why Republicans -- up and down the ballot -- are falling far behind Democrats in both fundraising and infrastructure.
Canadians are eyeing moves to these cities for more affordable housing
Faced with elevated housing prices, half of Canadians in the country's largest cities are considering moving to places with more affordable housing.
Canadians' interest in buying EVs fades as barriers, concerns remain: J.D. Power
A new study finds fewer Canadians say they're interested in buying an electric vehicle as concerns remain about limited driving ranges, high prices and a lack of charging stations.
McDonald's says US$18 Big Mac meal was an 'exception' and their prices haven't risen that much
McDonald’s is fighting back against viral tweets and media reports that it says have exaggerated its price increases.
Oilers rally to beat Stars, tie Western Conference Final
With the Edmonton Oilers down two goals late in the first period of Game 4, Rogers Place was quiet, fans seemingly bewildered at the early, quick scoring of the Dallas Stars and the slow start by the home team. Ryan McLeod's marker with six-and-a-half minutes in the opening frame left changed all that.