WINNIPEG
Winnipeg

    • 'We failed': Manitoba health authority admits to error that led to burial mix-up

    Share
    WINNIPEG -

    A northern Manitoba First Nations community and the province's health authority are searching for answers after a family received -- and buried -- the remains of the wrong person.

    "Shared Health accepts full responsibility for this error," Lanette Siragusa, the CEO of the provincial health agency, told reporters Friday.

    "It is our job to provide dignity, respect and compassion to all those who come into our care as well as to their loved ones. In this instance, we failed.

    "For that I offer, my sincere apologies to the family and community members."

    Siragusa said they have launched an internal investigation to determine not only what caused the error but also the steps needed to ensure it doesn't happen again.

    Shared Health confirmed Friday the body was under the care of the organization while an autopsy was taking place in Winnipeg in late July.

    The body was then released to a funeral home, and then to the family.

    A subsequent check alerted health officials to the mistake, but the body had already been buried.

    A preliminary investigation found that there were gaps on how remains are tracked in and out of the morgue, said Siragusa.

    The probe also found two other recent incidents where bodies were incorrectly signed out of Shared Health's facilities and transported to a funeral home. Siragusa said the errors were caught in time.

    The authority has already made some changes to prevent further mistakes. It has restricted access to its morgues while also limiting who may be able to sign out a body to a funeral home.

    Shared Health is also in the process of seeking an external review to look at current procedures and recommend additional ones.

    Siragusa said Shared Health will pay for exhuming the remains and for a new funeral.

    The leader of Pimicikamak Cree Nation in northern Manitoba confirmed the family involved is from their community.

    Chief David Monias said the body that was supposed to be sent up north was of Keith Wilson, 44, who was found in the Jack River in July near Norway House Cree Nation. Wilson had been reported missing in late June.

    Monias said the family and leadership were notified of the error this week.

    "We were just in shock in terms of what happened and in disbelief. Angry, of course," Monias said in a phone interview. "We proceeded to ask a whole bunch of questions in terms of what happened. Why did this happen? How could this happen?"

    He said the family had a wake in Pimicikamak and the burial was held in Norway House. It was a closed casket, Monias said, so the family was not aware they were burying the wrong person.

    Monias said he hopes to see a full investigation done along with support for the family.

    "(They're) being thrown back into the trauma," he said.

    "How do you compensate that?"

       This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 16, 2024.

     

    CTVNews.ca Top Stories

    A man who has brain damage has a murder conviction reversed after a 34-year fight

    A man who has brain damage and was sentenced to life in prison for the murder of a shopkeeper in London had his decades-old conviction quashed Wednesday by an appeals court troubled by the possibility police elicited a false confession from a mentally vulnerable man. Oliver Campbell, who suffered cognitive impairment as a baby and struggles with his concentration and memory, was 21 when he was jailed in 1991 after being convicted based partly on admissions his lawyer said were coerced. “The fight for justice is finally over after nearly 34 years," Campbell said. “I can start my life an innocent man.” Campbell, now in his 50s, was convicted of the robbery and murder of Baldev Hoondle, who was shot in the head in his shop in the Hackney area of east London in July 1990. He had a previous appeal rejected in 1994 and was released from prison in 2002 on conditions that could have returned him to prison if he got into trouble. Defense lawyer Michael Birnbaum said police lied to Campbell and “badgered and bullied” him into giving a false confession by admitting he pulled the trigger in an accident. He was interviewed more than a dozen times, including sessions without either a lawyer or other adult present. His learning disability put him “out of his depth” and he was "simply unable to do justice to himself,” Birnbaum said. He said the admissions were nonsense riddled with inconsistencies that contradicted facts in the case. At trial, he testified that he was not involved in the robbery and had been somewhere else though he couldn't remember where. A co-defendant, Eric Samuels, who has since died, pleaded guilty to the robbery and was sentenced to five years in prison. At the time, he told his lawyer Campbell was not the gunman and later told others Campbell wasn’t with him during the robbery. Lawyers continued to advocate for Campbell that he wasn't the killer and his case was referred to the Court of Appeal by the Criminal Cases Review Commission which investigates potential injustices. The three judges on the Court of Appeal rejected most of Birnbaum's grounds for appeal but said they were troubled by the conviction in light of a new understanding of the reliability of admissions from someone with a mental disability. The panel quashed the conviction as 'unsafe,' and refused to order a retrial.

    Shopping Trends

    The Shopping Trends team is independent of the journalists at CTV News. We may earn a commission when you use our links to shop. Read about us.

    Regina

    Saskatoon

    Edmonton

    Calgary

    Toronto

    Ottawa

    Montreal

    Atlantic

    Vancouver

    Vancouver Island

    Kelowna

    N.L.

    Northern Ontario

    Barrie

    Kitchener

    London

    Stay Connected
    Follow CTV News