Lawyers for alleged Winnipeg serial killer point to opinion poll in bid to get jury tossed
The lawyers of an alleged serial killer in Winnipeg are questioning whether pre-trial publicity in the high-profile case may have influenced the jury’s decision-making ability, after a public poll commissioned by the defence found 81 per cent of respondents believe the accused is guilty.
Jeremy Skibicki is charged with four counts of first-degree murder in the deaths of four Indigenous women: Rebecca Contois, Morgan Harris, Marcedes Myran, and a fourth unidentified woman who Indigenous have given the name Mashkode Bizhiki'ikwe or Buffalo Woman.
He has pleaded not guilty.
His defence lawyers’ bid to toss the jury in the trial continued Tuesday in Manitoba’s Court of King’s Bench.
READ MORE: Winnipeg trial of man accused of killing four women starts with bid to toss jury
Skibicki’s lawyers launched a constitutional question over the partiality of the jury, seeking to have the case heard by judge-alone and not a jury.
The argument hinges on a public opinion poll commissioned by Legal Aid Manitoba, which is representing Skibicki in the case. The poll, conducted by Mainstreet Research in February, posed questions to 906 Manitobans, all of whom were eligible for a jury.
The poll gathered thoughts on Skibicki and what respondents think of various potential defences in the case – such as a defence that he is not criminally responsible due to mental disorder.
The poll, which was released to the media by the court Tuesday, found – of the people aware of the Skibicki case – 81 per cent of respondents believed the accused was guilty based on what they had seen, read or heard about the case. The poll said 17 per cent were unsure, and 2 per cent said they believe he is not guilty.
Ninety-five per cent of the respondents aware of the case indicated they had a somewhat or strongly negative opinion of Skibicki, while only five per cent said they had a somewhat or strongly positive opinion.
The court heard on Monday the poll has a margin of error of +/- 3.3 per cent.
Expert witness Dr. Christine Ruva, a U.S.-based cognitive psychologist and professor told the court one of the reasons the poll was done was to assess bias in the community.
She has extensively studied the influence pre-trial publicity can have on jury decision-making in the United States, and said in this case, there has been a significant amount of coverage – more than 400 articles.
“The more pre-trial publicity, the more bias,” Ruva told the court.
When asked by Skibicki’s defence if a jurors opinion could change once evidence is presented in trial, Ruva said it’s unlikely.
“People’s belief in guilt stays roughly the same even after trial evidence if they have an opinion of guilt in the case after being exposed to pre-trial publicity,” she said.
She said the safest way to avoid unconscious jury bias is to only allow people to serve on a jury if they haven’t heard of the case before.
However, Crown prosecutor Christian Vanderhooft pushed back against Ruva’s testimony, pointing to the high-profile jury trial in the death of Tina Fontaine, a 15-year-old First Nations girl who was killed in Winnipeg.
The death and pre-trial coverage was significant, Vanderhooft said, but in that case, the jury acquitted the accused.
“Jurors and juries do in fact acquit people all the time – not everybody is found guilty,” Vanderhooft said.
Ruva agreed, but said her research is based on many cases, not one single case.
“I haven’t been on one yet where the person wasn’t found guilty,” she said.
In Skibicki’s case, a 12-person jury and two alternates were selected in April. The court heard Tuesday more than half indicated they hadn’t heard of this case before.
The matter continues in court Wednesday.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
BREAKING Group tied to Islamic State plotted fatal Ontario restaurant shooting: Crown
A gunman who is accused of killing a young Ontario man and shooting four of his family members at their small Mississauga restaurant in 2021 was allegedly part of a trio who had pledged allegiance to the listed terrorist group Islamic State, a Crown attorney said in an opening statement in the Brampton murder trial this week.
Board orders deportation for trucker in horrific Humboldt Broncos crash
The truck driver who caused the horrific bus crash involving the Humboldt Broncos junior hockey team has been ordered to be deported.
Trudeau responds to American senators calling on Canada to increase defence spending
Stopping short of offering the assurance U.S. senators are seeking, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said his government is aware there's more work to do in order to see Canada meet NATO's defence spending target.
Italian teenage computer wizard set to become the first saint of the millennial generation
Pope Francis paved the way for the canonization of the first saint of the millennial generation on Thursday, attributing a second miracle to a 15-year-old Italian computer whiz who died of leukemia in 2006.
Top Russian military officials are being arrested. Why is it happening?
It began last month with the arrest of a Russian deputy defense minister. Then the head of the ministry’s personnel directorate was hauled into court. This week, two more senior military officials were detained. All face charges of corruption, which they have denied.
'A really bad car crash': Why health experts are raising concerns over surging syphilis cases
A sexually transmitted infection (STI) that was once thought to be a thing of the past is now a public health priority for North American doctors.
Morgan Spurlock, Oscar-nominated director of 'Super Size Me,' dies at 53
Documentary filmmaker Morgan Spurlock, an Oscar-nominee who made food and American diets his life's work, famously eating only at McDonald's for a month to illustrate the dangers of a fast-food diet, has died. He was 53.
Milk sold in Canadian grocery stores tested for avian influenza; results released
As avian flu spreads south of the border, Canadian officials are now testing samples of milk sold in grocery stores across the country.
Leaving time on the table: Surveys show unused paid vacation, 'quiet vacationing'
'Quiet vacationing' is the latest new term to describe the rough edges of office culture, and survey data shows it's widespread among North American workers.