Veterans demand inquiry into motivations behind privacy violations
Veterans Ombudsman Guy Parent appears at a Senate veterans committee hearing on Oct. 19, 2011. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick)
By Murray Brewster, The Canadian Press
Published Wednesday, November 14, 2012 3:45PM CST
Last Updated Wednesday, November 14, 2012 6:36PM CST
OTTAWA -- The country's veterans ombudsman received nine privacy violation complaints over the last five years, seven of which were handed over to Canada's privacy commissioner -- a move questioned by a growing number of ex-soldiers.
A high-profile advocate, who claims his medical files were raided, wants the federal solicitor general to investigate whether it was appropriate for ombudsman Guy Parent to "take a back seat" on the issue.
He also asks whether the veterans minister overstepped his authority by shutting down a probe initiated by his predecessor.
Former warrant officer Harold Leduc, who was recently dropped from a federal agency that reviews benefits claims of ex-soldiers, says he believes his complaint about alleged privacy violations deserved to be investigated by both the ombudsman and privacy commissioner Jennifer Stoddart.
And a citizens group on the East Coast weighed into the issue Wednesday, demanding a public inquiry into what they say is a pattern of privacy violations at Veterans Affairs that targeted advocates.
A spokeswoman for Parent says each complaint was dealt with appropriately and denied the ombudsman had been usurped.
"As an independent body, the Office of the Veterans' Ombudsman does not back down from investigations on request," said Claude Rochon in an email statement.
"The decision to halt the review of this specific potential privacy breach was made when it was confirmed that the relevant mandated federal authority, in this case the Office of the Privacy Commissioner, had been seized with the matter.
"Parallel investigations by our office and the Office of the Privacy Commissioner would not have been a sensible use of resources."
Last week, it was revealed Veteran Affairs Minister Steven Blaney quietly ended one of the privacy probes by the ombudsman, which had been ordered by his predecessor, Jean-Pierre Blackburn.
Like Parent, Blaney said he believed that investigation was best handled by Stoddart. A few weeks ago the privacy commissioner, in a comprehensive audit, gave the department a thumbs-up and said its procedures for handling information have been tightened.
But that hasn't satisfied advocates, include a St. John's, N.L.-based organization active in supporting ex-soldiers.
"The federal government has been playing a shell-game with the truth," said Our Duty president Jeff Rose-Martland, who has written extensively on veterans issues.
He claims his organization has been made aware of dozens of unreported, alleged privacy violations and called for a full inquiry.
In addition to Leduc, another veteran, Tom Hoppe, one of the country's most decorated peacekeepers and a member of the ombudsman's advisory committee, had a complaint before Parent.
With no perceived action from the ombudsman, both men wrote the minister on June 4, 2012, imploring to Blaney to take further steps to protect personal information within the department, and to resolve their complaints.
"We applaud your recent efforts within your ministry to limit the future misuse of veterans' personal medical information within Veterans Affairs," they wrote in a joint letter, obtained by The Canadian Press.
"However, these changes do not address the damage caused to us by the acquisition and subsequent misuse of our medical information by senior members of your ministry."
Leduc wrote again on Sept. 27, 2012, but Blaney urged the former senior warrant officer to contact the privacy commissioner.
"As you are aware, the Veterans Review and Appeal Board is an independent tribunal and operates at arm's length from the minister of Veterans Affairs to ensure a fair appeal process for veterans and their families," said Blaney's reply last week, also obtained by The Canadian Press.
"Therefore with regard to your concerns about privacy, I would encourage you to contact the Office of the Privacy Commissioner, as previously recommended by my office."
A spokesman for Blaney said the department has been given clear direction to handle privacy complaints.
"Our officials have been clearly instructed to notify the privacy commissioner when informed of any evidence of a privacy breach and we invite any veteran who believes their privacy has been breached to immediately contact the office of the privacy commissioner without delay," said Niklaus Schwenker in an email note.
"Officials at the Department of Veterans' Affairs have been instructed to co-operate fully with the privacy commissioner in all cases."