Number of Manitobans who believe health restrictions are excessive on the rise: survey

The survey found 23 per cent of respondents believe our current restrictions are excessive, compared to 10 per cent in October of 2020. (File Image)

Winnpieg -

Nearly one-quarter of Manitobans now believe current pandemic public health orders are excessive, according to a new survey by Probe Research.

The opinion research firm surveyed 1,189 Manitoba adults about a variety of pandemic-related issues between Oct. 19 and 26. The survey had a margin of error of +/- 2.8 per cent.

The survey found 23 per cent of respondents believe our current restrictions are excessive, compared to 10 per cent in October of 2020.

(Source: Probe Research Inc.)

Southern Manitobans were most likely to say the orders are excessive, with 42 per cent of respondents agreeing versus 18 per cent among Winnipeggers. Of rural Manitoban respondents, 35 per cent said they thought the restrictions are excessive.

Men were also more likely than women to agree the orders are excessive, as were those with a high school diploma or less, younger adults, those who are not fully vaccinated against COVID-19, and PC supporters.

HEALTH OFFICIALS EARN HIGHER APPROVAL THAN POLITICAL LEADERS

The survey also found Manitobans are more likely to praise public health leaders versus political leaders.

When asked to rate Manitoba’s Chief Public Health Officer Dr. Brent Roussin’s performance, for example, 39 per cent of respondents said they strongly approve, 34 per cent said they somewhat approve, 16 per cent said they somewhat disapprove, and 11 per cent said they strongly disapprove.

This gave Dr. Roussin a 73 per cent approval rating, compared to Manitoba Premier Kelvin Goertzen’s 61 per cent approval rating.

When asked to rate Goertzen’s performance, 14 per cent of respondents said they strongly approve, 47 per cent of respondents somewhat approve, 25 per cent somewhat disprove, and 14 per cent strongly disapprove.

(Source: Probe Research Inc.)

Manitoba Health Minister Audrey’s Gordon, meanwhile, had a 53 per cent approval rating, with six per cent saying they strongly approve of her performance, 47 per cent of respondents saying they somewhat approve, 27 per cent saying they somewhat disapprove, and 20 per cent saying they strongly disapprove.

Manitoba Chief Nursing Officer Lanette Siragusa and Vaccine Implementation Task Force Medical Lead Dr. Joss Reimer also had strong approval ratings, with 76 per cent and 78 per cent respectively.

GOERTZEN’S APPROVAL RATING DOUBLES PALLISTER’S

While Premier Goertzen’s approval rating didn’t rival Dr. Roussin’s, it did double that of predecessor Brian Pallister.

According to Probe Research, Pallister’s approval rating was at 41 per cent in Oct. 2020 and 29 per cent in June 2021, compared to Goertzen’s 61 per cent from the most recent survey in October 2021.

(Source: Probe Research Inc.)

RATING THE PROVINCE’S HEALTH, ECONOMIC PERFORMANCE

The survey also found only half of Manitobans approve of the government’s health and economic performance.

Fifty per cent of respondents said they approve of how the province is navigating protecting Manitobans’ health during the pandemic - a slight increase from Oct. 2020 when 46 per cent approved, but a sharp decrease from June of 2020 when 77 per cent approved.

(Source: Probe Research Inc.)

On the economic front, 49 per cent of respondents approved of the province’s performance, up from 45 per cent in October 2020 and down from 61 per cent in June 2020.

RATING OUR PRAIRIE NEIGHBOURS

Meanwhile, three-quarters of Manitobans believe their province did a better job compared to Alberta and Saskatchewan.

Seventy-seven per cent of respondents agree Manitoba has done a better job of dealing with the pandemic than our prairie neighbours.

(Source: Probe Research Inc.)

However, 69 per cent of respondents agree Manitoba has been more reactive than proactive in dealing with the pandemic, compared to 74 per cent in October 2020.

The survey also found Winnipeg respondents were most likely to say Manitoba performed better than Alberta and Saskatchewan, with 80 per cent strongly or somewhat agreeing, compared to 65 per cent in southern Manitoba and 76 per cent in rural or northern Manitoba.

Respondents with a higher level of education and who are fully vaccinated are most likely to endorse Manitoba’s pandemic performance over our western counterparts.

Another key takeaway from the Probe Research study – eight in 10 Manitobans believe Manitoba should take patients from outside of the province.

The complete survey summary can be found here.